Monday, May 2, 2011

On Osama bin Laden and Death Parties

Hi there. I'm a little torn at the moment on what has eventuated over the last 24 hours, so I'm going to use this as a medium for me to get my thoughts out there. My views might be a little controversial, especially compared with my US colleagues,  but bear with me, I'll do my best to arrive at a decent conclusion by the end of it.

Unless you have been living under a rock (and more so than Mr Osama was), you are undoubtedly aware of the death of Osama bin Laden in semi-rural Pakistan. There's no denying the significance of this - the world's most wanted man, on the run for more than a decade, finally brought to justice in one sense or another. But the circumstances of this "justice", and the reaction to it, brings up a number of questions.

I'll start off with the reaction. I learned of bin Laden's death as I was leaving a theatre on Park Street at around 12:30AM. Immediately I heard the cheers coming from Boston Common, which I quickly learned were a part of this celebration. At the same time, there was a huge party on my own school's campus, which was apparently the greatest party Bentley had ever seen, cumulating in a couch burning.



Like I said before, I appreciate the significance of this. But is partying and getting drunk the right way to react to it? More importantly, what would have been the reaction if bin Laden had been captured, rather than killed? It just seems wrong, all things considered, to celebrate the killing of a man, regardless of what he may have done in his lifetime. At the same time, it's been ten long years of brutal wars and heartache for the American people. I guess the flip-side to my argument is that finally, they have what many consider to be the ultimate success in this war on terror which is essentially a reaction to the attacks of September 11, 2001. 

I think that this is more a spontaneous reaction to the release of frustration which has built up over 10 years of quite literally nothing. We have had no news of bin Laden's whereabouts since October 2001, where he was seen in the mountains on the border of Pakistan and Afghanistan. Suddenly, not only do we have a mere hint of where he is, we found EXACTLY where he is and we shot him in the head. I appreciate the relief that comes after so much frustration.

I've been to Ground Zero on multiple occasions now, and met with survivors of the attacks as well as those who lost many people in them and I've heard their stories. They are absolutely heartbreaking on every level. To see the man who quite literally boasted about his involvement in these attacks taken down in a similarly brutal manner has to bring some kind of closure to these people. But I relate the way in which my fellow students reacted to this to the way in which supporters of the quasi-Islamist movement bin Laden led reacted following 9/11. How can we say we're better than these extremists if there is no difference in our reactions to the success of our respective military operations? After all, bin Laden always claimed his motivation for 9/11 was the United States' support of Israel in the Lebanese conflict (Source)

I would suggest it would be better if had he been captured - he could have been brought to trial, almost definitely been sentenced to death in a court of law, and have lost a substantial amount of his "martyr" appeal at the same time. I believe he did say he would much rather fight to the death than be taken alive, and the reason is obvious (Source). One of the biggest threats to global security now is the potential for bin Laden to be seen as a martyr, and the information the US has released thus far is propagating such a view in the minds of his adherents.

I'm wondering, however, the broad implications of bin Laden's death. Do people seriously believe they are substantially safer now than they were yesterday? I'm hearing quotes like "We can bring all the troops home", "I don't have to worry about security when travelling anymore" and "we can cut down on airport security now, we're all safe!". This displays a fundamental lack of understanding in the workings of a Jihadist organization. Yes, the death of their spiritual leader is a moral blow to other members of Al-Qaeda. But we're talking about people who are massively passionate about the cause in which they believe. If anything, this is going to put westerners in more danger - hence why the US and Australia (amongst others, I'm sure) have issued a global travel warning for their citizens. The fight against fundamentalist/extremist Islam is far from over, and if the US truly wants this to make a difference, they now have to focus on convincing potential adherents that this man was far from a hero. If the US puts their mind to it, it shouldn't be that tough to paint him in a broadly negative light which appeals to those who would otherwise see him as a hero.

My final thought is simply on the location of bin Laden when he was found. He wasn't hiding in a cave in some lawless area of northern Pakistan, he was in a relatively significant town, near a Pakistani military base! It has to raise some questions. But there are plenty of others who can ask them.

I'm out of here, it's time for How I Met Your Mother. I'll give a wrap-up of my time at Bentley soon, can't wait to get on the road again, it's going to be legen- wait for it - dary.
-Jon

No comments:

Post a Comment